This study examined governance and security sector reform in Africa, with particular emphasis on how civilian oversight can be enhanced to strengthen accountability and security-sector professionalism in post-conflict South Sudan. The study pursued four objectives: to assess the effectiveness of formal civilian oversight mechanisms; examine the contribution of customary justice systems, traditional authorities and civil society actors where formal oversight is weak; analyse the influence of political and ethnic patronage on disarmament, demobilisation and reintegration and the unification of armed forces under the R-ARCSS; and assess the effectiveness of accountability mechanisms in addressing abuses, impunity and unchecked authority within the military, police and intelligence services. The study adopted pragmatism as its overarching research paradigm permitting the researcher to draw on different forms of evidence where each contributes to answering the research questions. The quantitative sample was determined using a probability-based sample-size procedure appropriate to the size and structure of the accessible population. n0 = Z²pq/e², where n0 was the initial sample size, Z was the standard normal value corresponding to the selected confidence level, p was the estimated proportion of the population possessing the characteristic of interest, q was 1-p, and was the desired margin of error. Using the conventional 95 percent confidence level, Z = 1.96. Where no defensible prior population proportion was available, p = 0.50 and q = 0.50 were used. At a margin of error of 0.05, the initial large-population estimate was approximately 384 respondents and the verified accessible population was applied using n = n0/[1 + (n0 - 1)/N], where N represented the accessible population. The findings showed that formal civilian oversight was institutionally present but operationally weak, particularly in budgetary scrutiny, access to information, technical capacity, independence and the practical ability to influence security-sector conduct. Community, customary and civil-society actors made useful contributions through local information, mediation and social accountability, but their effectiveness was constrained by limited civic space, intimidation risks and weak formal channels for acting on their evidence. DDR and force-unification processes were adversely affected by perceived political and ethnic patronage, including concerns about recruitment, rank harmonisation, merit, command relationships and resource allocation. Accountability mechanisms were weakest at the stages linking complaints to impartial investigation, sanction, victim redress and protection from retaliation, while impunity remained a major obstacle to reform. The study concludes that sustainable security-sector reform requires civilian oversight to operate as a connected governance system in which legal mandates are supported by information access, institutional capacity, autonomy, enforceable accountability, community participation and transparent personnel and resource-management systems. The thesis proposes an integrated civilian oversight-security professionalism framework and provides institutional and policy recommendations for strengthening democratic security governance in South Sudan.
Security Sector Reform; Civilian Oversight; Accountability; DDR; Force Unification; Professionalism; South Sudan.
International Journal of Trend in Scientific Research and Development - IJTSRD having
online ISSN 2456-6470. IJTSRD is a leading Open Access, Peer-Reviewed International
Journal which provides rapid publication of your research articles and aims to promote
the theory and practice along with knowledge sharing between researchers, developers,
engineers, students, and practitioners working in and around the world in many areas
like Sciences, Technology, Innovation, Engineering, Agriculture, Management and
many more and it is recommended by all Universities, review articles and short communications
in all subjects. IJTSRD running an International Journal who are proving quality
publication of peer reviewed and refereed international journals from diverse fields
that emphasizes new research, development and their applications. IJTSRD provides
an online access to exchange your research work, technical notes & surveying results
among professionals throughout the world in e-journals. IJTSRD is a fastest growing
and dynamic professional organization. The aim of this organization is to provide
access not only to world class research resources, but through its professionals
aim to bring in a significant transformation in the real of open access journals
and online publishing.